SD3 seems afraid of me because I discipline her...
So this is a kind of weird issue I'm having and I'm not sure what to do :? My fiance and I have full custody of his daughter who is 3 years old. I am not a strict parent but I strongly believe in teaching her to be polite, ask for things nicely, help clean her room, that sort of thing. As a result, I have found myself in the position of disciplinarian which I'm sure many of you can relate to. My SD3 and I get along just fine and for the most part she behaves very well. The only thing is that I think she is a bit afraid of me which is causing me a lot of frustration. Let me first say that I hardly ever raise my voice to her and I absolutely do not believe in spanking or any kind of physical punishment such as that. I will use a strong tone when she is misbehaving though and unfortunately I do find myself being the one that has to correct her behavior the most. My fiance will also discipline her if she is misbehaving but he is so absent-minded half the time that he doesn't notice it or dismisses a lot of her behavior for one reason or another. I don't believe in disengaging either as I feel this is a duty I have taken on and she needs a mother in her life as her biological one is currently in prison. I also do plan on adopting her and I love her very much. The issue is that now she seems to tiptoe around me with everything, even when I'm not angry at her. Just this morning I walked into her room and said, "Ok honey it's time to go." and she just stares at me while moving all slowly out of her room as if I had just yelled at her or something. She does this staring thing often and it's driving me insane. Last night I asked her to go potty and then take her clothes off so I can bathe her. She went then started pulling her underwear back up so I reminded her nicely that she is taking a bath and that her clothes need to come off. She just stared at me and slowly brought her underwear back up. I had to tell her again that she needs to remove them and started to lose my patience a little. This sort of thing happens a lot lately where she just stares at me with this look as if I just punished her and often does the opposite of what she has been asked to do. I know it's not malicious, she just seems to have a hard time paying attention or something. I thought maybe it's just her age and she's still trying to figure things out but she doesn't act this way with my fiance. I know my patience is something I need to work on but I get so discouraged when everytime I approach her she looks at me as if I'm going to yell at her I don't want her to be afraid of me but I don't believe in raising a child who is badly behaved either and I will continue to correct her when she is acting up. I'm just starting to feel a bit left out from the loving aspect of our relationship because she is just all about daddy lately. She still tells me she loves me here and there and I know she seeks my approval a lot but I want to try and find a balance with her and I'm not sure how. I want her to understand how much I love her and that I'd do anything to keep her safe but also that I don't tolerate bad behavior. It's just hard to sit down with her and try and tell her all that as she is still young and her comprehension isn't fully developped yet. I also want to note that I make sure she and I get to bond so I do things with her such as painting her nails, reading stories, watch movies & cuddle, play... I guess I'm just hoping someone else might have a suggestion or advice on how I could handle discipline with her in a manner that doesn't always make me the bad guy. Thank you for reading.
Firstly SM (step moms) do not
Firstly SM (step moms) do not recommend disengaging as a norm. Just when there is no other option for you to do with out of control step kids whose biological parents fail to discipline them. Sounds to me as if SD3's biological father is letting you be the disciplinarian in the house. Not really fair to you. Your SD3 probably has taken note that the one "yelling" or using a forceful voice is mainly you. You are the authority figure. She is at the age where they start to want to learn their independence a little (if they have well adjusted parenting) and so she is just testing your boundaries a bit. She may be a little confused as to why you get upset with her and her dad doesn't (because he is so absent minded). Really just explain to her why you tell her to do things and give her some positive feedback when you do have to correct her and she follows through. Maybe if you feel you aren't being patient enough then try leaving her vicinity for a few moments and taking a few breaths and counting backwards from 20. Sounds pretty normal to me for this age and since you are baring the brunt of the disciplining. I would also suggest MAKING dad do some of the disciplining or having fun days just the two of you so she associates you with rewards for her good behavior.
My SD10 used to do things
My SD10 used to do things that would drive me up the wall when she was this age (3, 4, 5). I was incredibly strict. She'd try and walk out of the bedroom way past her bedtime and I'd just look at her and point her back to the room. She'd get in the bed and cry into her pillow. I'd turn off the tv and she'd turn it back on and I'd go back and tell her not to dare turn the tv on again. She'd cry some more. She'd stare at people that were guests in our home when they said hello and wouldn't respond. Sometimes, she'd turn and walk away from them. I'd follow her and make her go back and say hello to everyone. At first, she'd tell her mother that I was mean to her and that she didn't want to come over. When her mother would call my DH he would dismiss her complaints. When he'd ask me what happened I'd simply say "One day you'll thank me for teaching her manners because she's being raised like an animal." Sure enough, the little girl is actually much more well mannered now that she is 10. We get along well, I actually took her with me to a sleepover at my sisters house last weekend and she had an amazing time. She has told me that I'm scary, but she says it with a smile.
Thank GOD for parents like
Thank GOD for parents like you! It's refreshing to see that there are STILL some parents in the western world that have EXPECTATIONS (gasp!) of children and not just treat them like pampered poodles!!
Wait, scratch that. Even PAMPERED POODLES have SOME expectations of them (house breaking, etc)
This is exactly how I would
This is exactly how I would parent my SD3 as she grows up if her father will let me. She really is a wonderful child 90-95% of the time, but 5-10% of the time she gets selfish, whiny, and bad-mannered. When she's grumpy, she won't say Hello... She'll hide behind her father or bury her head in his shoulder. He does a great job trying to cherish the time he has with her while she's young, but he neglects using her young, impressionable years to try to teach her that, yes, you must speak when someone says Hello to you, even if you're in a bad mood. He attributes that to the fact that she's just grumpy and knows that it's rare... Which I understand too, but I can see the flip side.
He also doesn't make her fetch things she asks for when she's in that mood. She'll ask him to get her juice box across the room and he will submit to her whimpers instead of reasoning with her that she is just as close as he is to her drink & just as capable of getting her own drink. I believe that she will grow up embracing that pouty attitude and using it to get her way in all things.
She loves me and looks to me for approval in a lot of ways, but when he's around, it happens less. I sometimes feel like the third wheel... He's a great dad, but his parenting skills need fine-tuning, in my opinion.
The issue I have with him is that he puts her up on a pedestal so much... He gave her his middle name & last name so that, even if she got married, she'd still keep his name somehow. He wants to get a tattoo as a tribute to her being his daughter. He puts forth so much energy towards her that I sometimes wonder if he could ever love another child like that... I know he'd be a great dad to our children if we were to have them, but I can't shake the feeling that I'd constantly be comparing them to SD3. I think they'd be second best. I know he wants more kids, but I've always doubted my emotional availability as a parent. I see my patience short with SD3 all too often. I try very hard, and I do pretty good... but I just don't think I am cut from "parenting cloth."
Any advice would be appreciated.
With a 3 year old, it is all
With a 3 year old, it is all about repetition. They reasoning part of their brains have not formed yet. You are doing the right thing by being consistent with her. Obviously you are the only one that is attempting to teach her at this point. I think the best way to get your point across and to help her not be afraid of you is to temper it with tickles and hugs.