Custody 50-50.....does anyone have and how is it working?
Forums:
My dh and I are back in court this year over access time and spousal support payments (trying to get her off the payroll). We want to obtain 50-50. It will be a fight but worth it. Just wondering if anyone else has this arrangement...how does it work and is it working for you?
Thanks
Are you asking for 50/50
Are you asking for 50/50 because you truely want the kids or because you are "trying to get her off the payroll"?
50/50
Good questions....we truly want our step daugther. The child support we would be willing to continue to pay her the same amount. We have decided that we will not change that. We want her in our lives and our kids lives more. We feel that she seems to adjust better when she is with us for longer periods of time versus this one night a week thing and then every other weekend. We are tired of her having to carry her suitcase to school. We will provided her with all the things she needs here..clothes, toiletries..whatever
The payroll part is all the money we pay her for spousal support. I agree that there is a transitional period...so far almost 5 years...but the time has come where she needs to let go. She has a gym membership, nails done, tanning salon, drives a big SUV, shops all the time, hair appointments, etc. Not my business but I can't stand us paying for all that. She tried to get my money as well.
I know every situation is different. I know you have pain but she caused a lot of pain to a lot of people. She had an affair with her best friends husband. I am close to her and the things that my dh's ex did to him and her are unbelievable....JERRY SPRINGER material for sure.
We are only wanting what we think is best for the children. She wants to spend more time with us (she has asked) and her brother. We did put our son in the same daycare that she is in so that she could visit him every day.(even if that means I have to see her and trust me that is no picnic for me)
My husband is a good dad and his ex is a good mom. So why can't we have 50%?
50/50 is good
It depends what state you are in. But our 50/50 through the courts is this; 50/50 placement with SD she is with us every other week Mon thru Sun. My husband still pays child support but that is only because his ex makes less money than he does. The court considers the ex's income and my husband's child support is based on the difference between the two incomes (my income in not included). His ex actually went down in income but the courts would not give her more money, they base it on her potential to make a certain income not her actual income. He previously had 100% placement and she paid him support. When I first came into the family he had 50/50 placement but only had the SD on the weekends - I am the one who suggested every other week due to the fact the weekends to her appeared to be party time and I felt we needed structure. It seems to work out well.
I'm sorry I can't be of much
I'm sorry I can't be of much help with htis topic. We just have everyother weekend with my ss. My hubby tried for more but got denied by the courts. Good luck
bettyboop
Beetyboop I would be interested in what you have to say because you sit on the other side. I am a Biomom as well and I am not sure how I would handle things. You never know till you are there.
thanks
Not to sound rude but it is
Not to sound rude but it is possible to want more time with the child without money being the motive. They are two seperate issues. Personally I think long term alimony is a crock of sh%$. Thankfully my hubby was never in this position. I absolulty understand and agree that child support is a must but paying child support and alimony....... That makes no sense to me at all to me.
When we go back to court
When we go back to court both issues have to be reviewed (we are in canada and that mandate was set at the last arbritration date). My dh did try talking to his ex last year about the custody issue but she refuses to discuss it until the court date. He will not change the child support payments...even though the table number say we will pay less. We don't want it to be about money. That is his child and he has to look after her. As I would except him to do with our child should we ever break up. I will look after myself (did it for the last 22 years).
We want what works best for the kids. So i guess what I was really wondering does the one week on one week off thing work or are there other ways to do it?
more time, no money
Like I stated earlier, I can only talk of WI child support/placement. Yes you can have 50/50 placement without affecting child support payments. Actually in WI they feel that the child needs to be with both parents equally - they see it as a positive. I have a nephew that thought he would try for 50/50 due to the monetary relief, but it didn't work in his favor financially, because he only participated in the 50/50 placement and thought it was good enough - his ex kept records of financial expenses and he ended up owing her $6,000 even though they were 50/50 with no child support payments.
Right now my boyfriend and I
Right now my boyfriend and I are not engaged nor are we living together so I can only speake from seeing the kids occasionally. He is a very involved father which I admire very much. I have full custody of my kids. My ex has only had our kids 7 times over night in a year and a half. My kids are older than his (13&14) and I know they are that age where friends are everything as well as their social life. You miss one sleep over and your social status plummets! My daughter did say to me one day that she felt sorry for my boyfriends girls. When I asked her why she said "because they have to go back and forth between their parents houses, I would hate that so much if I had to do that. I am just happy visiting dad". Now mind you this is coming from a 14 yr old girl. But I am sure it is difficult. Although my ex is living with his 26 year old girlfriend whom he left us for. I know my daughter is emberassed of her so that I would think has alot to do with her response.
Sky22, I was married for 16 years and was a stay at home mom for 14 of that time. My ex was in med school when I met him. We soon married and he started residency. I supported him and made way more money than he did during this time. I worked till I was 9 months pregnant and then we both thought it was important for me to stay home. He moonlighted on weekends to make ends meet. He career started taking off. He was publishing more and more in medical journals and was becoming well respected in his field. He was inreasingly gone more and more. He was being invited to give lectures and so on constantly. Fast forward, He decided after 11 years of marriage he was going to leave me and the kids for some resident. He ended coming back 4 months later. Today he is the world renowned expert in his field. I stayed at home while he was out furthering his education and fine tuning his expertice. Now he is gone, I only have a bachelors' and having not worked in 14 years the best I could hope to do is make minimum wage. My ex make in excess of a million a year. Why should I have to go back to work now that he decideds my kids are older and don't need me? I was awarded 9 years of spousal support which is almost unheard of where I live. I do everything for them and he does nothing. My time is absolutely worth something. He calls them every 4-5 days and if they are lucky he sees them for a quick dinner one night a week.
I havbe worked hard at raising my children and do not feel guilty that I don't have to work. You better believe I will drag his but back to court and get more support every year.
You go girl!
I agree with you 100%! Time for doc to experience some of his own medicine!
Lets just agree to disagree
Lets just agree to disagree for now. I wish I were able to stay home with my son and baby on the way. You got that and it just seems like your complaining that you missed out on working instead????? I can understand getting used to a certain lifestyle but the concept of entitlement bothers me.
I'm sure your a beautiful person and it is difficult to understand other peoples position until we have been there ourselves. So I apologize in advance if I am not 'getting' this concept. I honestly hope I am never in the position because it might change at that point
????I??????????
I made a choice and sacrificed my career to stay home and enable hin to persue his career. We thought it was the best thing to do. You are damn right I am entitled to spousal support. You have no idea everything I have done and what he has not done. I worked in a co-op preschool where I worked 3 days a week, I was on the board of the preschool and was fundraising chairman. I worked in my daughters class room 2 days a week, I have voulonteerd for my community, I get up every morning @ 5:45, pack my kids lunches, drive them to school. I do not have someone clean my home and never have. I am amazed that you think after 14 years of staying home with my children that all of a sudden since he has walked out on my and the kids and has zero involvement that I shouls get a job?? So my kids should have no one to come home to?? My ex makes a fortune and partly due to my support and moving around, yanking the kids out of school and starting new ones, all so he can have all the glory.
My ex has had 16 vacations with this woman in a year and a half. I have had one and that was with my kids to go to our beach house for the last time so I could sign the papers to sell it. I know it is hard to feel sorry for someone when financially they are ok, but I too have worked hard for what we have. We started out in a 50,000 house that was bought with my stock options. It hasn't always been this way. But I guarantee my pain is as real as anybody elses.
I too hope you never find yourself in the position where you husband decideds not to be a parent and walks out on you leaving you with no marketable skill and years of devotion to your family.
Don't worry
Bettyboop, I agree with you. If I am ever fortunate enough to give up my career and stay at home with my children (when I decide to have them), I will absolutely do it - however, I know how much work I do now at home, in addition to my career, and if my husband ever decided to end our marriage, I would absolutely go after him for spousal support. Not because I'm a gold digger, but when you give up your job to raise children, you are doing several jobs in one and NOT getting paid! You are a babysitter, you are a housekeeper, you are a cook, you are a chauffer, heck, you are even a love slave! So when your husband decides to take that for granted and trade you in for another woman, he should absolutely have to pay you back for all you have done.
So how do you feel when the
So how do you feel when the wife decides to take up with another man and takes the child away from the BD? Is she entitled to have that lifestyle? Did she not give up on things? I know it is two in a marriage but when my husband sensed things were wrong he asked her to go to counselling but she was in too far with her best friends husband already.
This man is an amazing man, father (we also have our own as well), and husband. We does everything he has to, to get more time with his daugther....coaches her soccer, goes to her school to visit her etc.
Like I said before every situation is differnt. I, too, do not understand spousal support when someone worked and/or was capable to make a better career for herself. Now his ex's parents are divorced and yes her mom stayed home with the kids for 20 years and yes she should be entitled to her fair share...HALF!!!! But not his ex....married 8 years....child for one year. No sympathy here!!!!!
I know how hard it is. I have a very demanding job. I have to travel for work...leave my fifteen month old behind. I am pregnant. I am a step mom. So I know it is hard. Okay so my one luxury is a cleaning lady every two weeks. I work because..one finacially I have to and two because I want to. If I could afford to stay home with my children I would in a heart beat. I can't do that. Once she is off the payroll maybe we can do things differently. For now I am blessed to have my life and I know it (okay could do without the exwife).
Nope...
In that situation, I do not think the wife is entitled to spousal support. And I may be really naive on the courts and how these things work, but if you can prove a spouse was unfaithful, doesn't that have an affect on the outcome of the divorce...such as spousal support rights and that type of thing?
In my husband's situation, since his wife was the unfaithful one and she knew it, she didn't try to go after his money. He owns his own farming operations and has a ton of equipment and land and such, and she didn't even bother to touch any of it - and she could have, his lawyer told him so. But I think she was guilty for what she had done and was trying to get out as quick as possible.
I personally think that if you become a stay-at-home mom and take on all of those duties and then you become divorced, spousal support should be determined by the number of years you were married (which may be the case). Obviously, someone married for 20 years should be entitled to a lot more than someone who was married for 8 years and only stayed at home for one year.
I so agree with you.
I so agree with you. Unfortunately, in Canada, at least in Ontario, it is a no fault divorce. I guess the courts were getting weighed down with he said she said cases.
Originally, when the separation happen she told hubby that she wouldn't go after his money. That song changed pretty fast. Especialy when it didn't work out for her and she wanted to come back and he said no way. Nothing like a woman scorned.
Not in Canada, don't know about U.S.
In Canada, it doesn't matter what the dynamics of the marriage breakdown are, it doesn't impact support.
Good For You!
Keep taking this good for nothing to court every year, get an accounting of his income and get as much child support, and spousal support as possible. People that walk out on their families because it becomes boring need to pay the penalty. Were having too many screwed up kids becoming screwed up adults because of this rampant lifestyle that has over taken our country. It doesn't work for the children involved, and don't be surprised if your kids get to the point they don't even want to see him. Thats pretty much the norm, but when that becomes the case so be it; you got the better end of the deal. Your Kids! He lost his family, and I predict he'll go through a number of young ones over the years.
My ex and I did the 50/50 thing
And I think it was great for my kids. Only because it was not there decision but mine and it was not fair to him or them to take them away like they were solely mine. SO it worked good. Now because we live and hour and 1/2 away he only gets them every other weekend. And it seems ok..
But the 50/50 thing I think it should be for all its fair to the kids mostly. it lets them know that both parents want them and want to keep both parents equally involved..
Happy JMO
50/50 is a struggle
I have actually been doing the 50/50 thing with my ex for 2 1/2 years now. When my daughter was 8 years old, she came to me and said she had spent the last 6 years with only me most of the time and she thought it was unfair to her daddy and so she wanted to give him time with her also. I suspect he had something to do with her decision, but nontheless, this is what she wanted. It totally broke my heart. I told her that I was not about to give up my daughter completely, but that I did understand that her daddy is as much of a parent as I am and does deserve to see her on a daily basis just as much as I did. So I agreed to split the time. When it is his w/e he also has her the following week. When I get her back the next w/e then that following week is my time to have her. It has had its ups and downs. I do not think this would have ever worked from the beginning though. I think it takes 2 people that get along with each other to make this situation a success. Don't get me wrong, my ex and I definately have our differences. We don't always see eye to eye and we don't always agree on what is best for our daughter. What I try to keep in mind and I also remind him is that we wouldn't have even if we were still together. We always make sure that she doesn't play us against each other. For example, if she doesn't get her way at my house and says she wants to go stay with her daddy full time, he doesn't let her. She has to answer to us both. There is much more on this topic that I would like to share with you but have run out of time at the moment. I will get back with you on some suggestions that have worked for us and also some things you might want to keep in mind as you make this very important decision. There are a lot of pros and cons. Good luck
Thank you. Lookign forward
Thank you. Lookign forward to hearing the pros and cons.
Enjoy your evening
50/50
This 50/50 situation worked wonderfully for us for about a year. It's not horrible now but I'll get to that. When we first started this time share with my ex we were both single. She had her own room and all his attention. All was great until he realized that being a full time parent sometimes means an inconvenience to his life style. He was never used to having to leave work early because the school called and she is sick. Or that he would have to spend most of the evening at school for a function or at the ball field. Not only was he not used to it, he also never got used to it. If she gets sick at school during his week I still have to go get her. He will not go pick her up. He always has some excuse about his job that prevents him from being able to pick her up. He even sent her to school last week when she was running over a 100 temp. She told me that he took her tempature that morning and then just gave her some meds and sent her on. Guess who had to go pick her up before the day was over. I can't force him to do these things, yet I also can't leave her there knowing she doesn't feel good. He refuses to take her to her ball practices. He says its too much running around and he can't afford the gas. So he leaves her with me during those days. I have her 2 to 3 days of his week during ball season because of this. I don't mind doing this for her because I know she really wants to do this and if I don't do it then she doesn't get to play. My problem with this situation is that since we have changed to this 50/50 schedule, he no longer pays child support. He doesn't offer to help with any expenses or send her with any money during these times. My daughter is also starting to see that he only wants to be there when it is convenient for him and this really hurts her feelings. Now she feels that she has got her self in a position that she can't get out of. A couple of times she has told him that she wants to move back home with me and go back to our old schedule. Her makes her feel quilty about it and so she changes her mind. I honostly don't think that is really what she wants. I think she wants him to be a full time daddy when he is suppose to be and he isn't and that hurts her feelings. My ex and I both just got married again last year. Within a month of each other. This has also changed her situation in both households. She now has a step brother and a step sister in both households. At our home she has acquired a step sister that has just turned 18. They adore each other. They are always together when the are both at home. It is really sweet. She has a step brother at our home that she also gets along with. At her dads she has a step brother that is 5 years older than her and a step sister that is 6 months older. She complains that they get away with everything and she always gets the blame for any trouble. I know how kids can be so I didn't pay it much mind. But then in one of my conversations with her dad he said she is always getting stuff started and his skids like to keep to themselves. My daughter has always been outgoing and can not keep to herself. She just doesn't have that ability. I don't like to judge much about what is going on in their household because I'm not there. I just think that if it gets too bad then she will finally just move back home full time regardless of what he wants. I know you are on the other side of this situation but I hope that I have opened up your eyes to situations that you may not have even thought mattered much to the kids. I do wish you the best. Let me know how it turns out.
Good or Bad..I think to
Good or Bad..I think to understand what we are getting into fully is wise. Jump one to many times without knowing the facts.
We are lucky in that dad and mom are both active in SD's life. They both want more of her. We just don't have enough. His ex has not remarried so things again could change. A crystal ball would be nice.
Thanks for sharing your story with me. I wish you and her daugther luck. I am sure it is hard on her. Good luck
KEEP TRACK
you should keep a book and document all of this, if he is not pulling 50/50 he will owe you money.
It’s amazing the kind of
It’s amazing the kind of emotion the topic of money can bring up.........
I'm sorry if I offended anyone, that wasn't my intention. I just have a different view ~ probably than most. I was taught to pull myself up by the bootstraps and if I decided to end my marriage I believe that also means cutting ties to each other’s wallets. Isn't being divorced about moving on. How can you move on while still being bound financially? I just don't get it. The assets we had at the time of the divorce should be divided 50/50 but any money coming in after that should be off limits. Of course child support should be figured. But then again its just my opinion... and we all know opinions are like as$holes, we all have them.
NO offence taken here. I am
NO offence taken here. I am of the same mindset as you. I guess I just understand that not all people are the same nor are the situation. Me, personally, I wouldn't want a dime. Just look after the kids. I can look after myself. Maybe that is another reason I work. When my ex and I split (no kids) we just went our separate ways. In fact he left me with a house that we had just purchased (had not moved in yet). That I couldn't afford and that needed a ton of renovation. He wanted nothing to do with it. At first I thought what the hell am I going to do....so I renovated with my bare hands. Two years later I sold it..price war got over my asking price. Then the ex wants his share....no way in hell.
My dad taught me to be a strong woman and that I am.
I can see where things may be differnt for others. Not saying they aren't strong woman because most of them are going ten jobs while their husband are advancing their careers. I guess I am a bleeding heart as well. If the guy burns you by taking up with someone younger after making his millions...hell shouldn't you get some compensation. In the end I hope he gets his!!!! What comes around goes around.
The state I am in is a no
The state I am in is a no fault state. I had PLENTY of documentation as to his horrible behavior, his unilateral decisions and his untaithfulness. It doesn't matter here if someone is unfaithful, it only matters if they spend marital money on that person.
As to being entitled to money he makes after the marriage is over, my ex has published books and he will continue to recieve royalties forever. Guess what, I am entitled to half the royalties FOREVER. I know it is not your intention to offend anyone but you have. Can I ask how long you were married and how long to your current spouse?
And as for the woman scorned comment, it has nothing to do with being scorned, it has to do with what is fair and equitable.
First of all I have tried to
First of all I have tried to be very respectful. If you have taken offense, once again I apologize but that doesn't change my mindset. And I never said a word about being 'scorned.' You sound like a very nice woman. And I am sorry that your ex treated you so badly and hopefully you will find someone in the future that will care for you the way you deserve.
To answer your question I have been with my husband for 6 years total and married for 4.
All my husband has to his
All my husband has to his name is some power tools and an old beat-up Toyota pick-up truck with like 7 billion miles on it. I am also a stay-at-home mom who gave up my career and I have sacrificed plenty for my husband's job (US Marine). I, too, would find it hard to support myself if we split up. But you know what? I do not want either his tools or his truck, I'd never want to bleed him dry and if I find myself suddenly single again for any reason, well, I'll do what any other responsible adult does and GET A JOB to support myself. I didn't choose to be a stay-at-home mother for MY HUSBAND, I did it for MY CHILDREN and for MYSELF. And no one owes me a thing for that. It's been my privilege. Seeing my children's smiling faces every day is all the payment I'll ever need.
As for 50/50, I've never done that, but I would think it would be dreadfully hard if there's bad communication and poor cooperation between the two households, especially if we're discussing school-aged children. We wanted to pursue 50/50, but because we lived so far away, we were discussing leaving the kids with BM during the school year and us taking them during the school breaks, summer vacation, etc. If the 50/50 thing doesn't work out, maybe a school year/summer vacation split would be an option.
~ Anne ~
First of all you have no
First of all you have no earthly idea what I have been through. Secondly, I HAVE NOT BLED HIM DRY. How dare you say something so curt! I am a responsible adult. My ex never sees our kids so I am here trying to hold it together for them.
By the way, my ex is getting 70% of his income while me and the kids get 30%. I have full custody, he buys them NOTHING. And I TOO stayed at home for my children as well and have done a damn good job of it. And yes, he sure as hell owes me. What a B*tch!
Amen, sister!
Believe me, there is absolutely no reason that a man (or woman) should ever be able to walk away and forget they had a family. You have every right to be supported so that you can raise your children in the life style that he was educated by you to provide for them. Missy resident didn't help him to reach any of those goals (except for the one below the belt probably!), so I agree with you completely.
The comparisons that some people are making are not remotely similar. Besides, what is right for you is right for you...nobody else can judge for their computer chair.
me too!
I also agree with this statement Just because I would not 'do' things the same as you does not mean I am at all judging you.
Tsk, tsk, tsk...
Wow, nice mouth! Someone doesn't play well with others...!
I was just expressing an opinion about what I would do as far as requesting spousal support. I wouldn't need it or want it and, frankly, I wouldn't project a sense of entitlement to receive it. I don't feel the need to get paid to be a mother to my children or a wife to my husband. Apparently, you do need it and you do want it. Okay. You're getting it, so what's your problem? Why is your opinion more valid than mine? Oh, wait... because YOU HAVE MONEY! That means your opinion is worth more, right?! That gives you the right to call people names because they have an opinion that differs from yours. Okay, now I get it!
Shame on you, bettyboop! This is a free country (thanks in part to my husband, who spent 20 years of his life fighting for your right to call me a bitch in a public forum) so I will express my opinion, whatever it may be. Disagreeing with you, honey, doesn't make someone a bitch.
By the way, I wasn't commenting specifically to you. It was a general comment about my feeling on whether or not I would want spousal support, which I wouldn't. If you took that personally, well, it brings to mind a line from Hamlet... "The lady doth protest too much, me thinks!" If you saw yourself in my comment it's not because I put you there.
You know, you seem to blame others a lot and that's really too bad. You called me a bitch for expressing an opinion and your other post said that we're all wrong, we don't know what it's like and we live in glass houses. Grow up, bettyboop, and maybe the next guy won't dump you for another woman.
~ Anne ~
Maybe after you remove that
Maybe after you remove that giant chip from your shoulder you can grow up. I have no reason to continue to exchange anything with someone like you. You don't have the first f*cking clue as to my life or what it has entailed. Oh and by the way, It is a free country in part due to my grandfather , father, uncle, brother, and exhusband. And thanks alot, that is really helpful, hopefully your next guy won't dump you for another woman. Nice. Oh and yes you are right, it is a free country and I can call someone a b*tch if it is fitting so wear that shoe honey.
betty...
I've noticed that most of your posts are basically bitching about your ex and his new young girlfriend, how he did you wrong, how you're taking him for all you can etc. I haven't seen a whole lot in the department of asking/giving advice or venting about step parenting. You seem to really have a lot of hatred for us stepmoms, and you're really judgemental in a lot of your posts. Try to remember that this is a place for us step parents, so maybe if step parenting isn't what you're here for another site would be better suited for you? I didn't see anything in Anne's post that would qualify her as being a bitch at all...
Good point!
Surely there's a BitterEx-WivesTalk.org forum somewhere! LOL Oh, Betty, what else can I say?! The more you talk, the more you prove my point. I'm done with this.
~ Anne ~
Wait a minute....cut out the nonsense...
It is starting again... Bettyboop did voice an opinion and although the response wasn't directly offensive...it was a passive aggressive way of stating that getting spousal support was not a positive thing to do and that someone doesn't need to be paid to be a mother to their children. That is judgmental. Relax people...if someone is expressing anger at her situation, how is that any different that our expressions of anger and frustration at sks. Why does their have to be so much self righteousness on a site that is supposed to be about support? Sometimes comments are taken personally because they worded in this way.
I got the "dig" inherent in the message and it had nothing to do with me.
Don't sweat about this Bettyboop...your feelings are totally understandable. I commend you for sharing the things that you did. You have to be a bit careful on this site...sometimes it can be a bit cliquish.
We do the 100:0 thing...
I have the kids %100 of the time and he never takes care of them %0. I guess it worked okay for him and it definitely works fine for me, although it is a lot of responsiblity and work. Yes, I do all of those household duties and work two jobs making an excellent income and am working at putting my kids through college...proud of it Do I get child support...you bet! This isn't something that I do for me, but rather for my kids. They benefit from the extra that he provides. Sometimes when you play, you gotta pay! Unfortunately the kids do too in not having a relationship with them...his choice...I can't change that.
Anne, you understand me :)
Anne I agree 100 % with this statement!
"I'll do what any other responsible adult does and GET A JOB to support myself. I didn't choose to be a stay-at-home mother for MY HUSBAND, I did it for MY CHILDREN and for MYSELF. And no one owes me a thing for that. It's been my privilege. Seeing my children's smiling faces every day is all the payment I'll ever need."
Wish we had 50/50 too.
My DH felt that since he left his ex-wife after 13 years, it was unfair of him to seek custody....his ex wife expected to be married forever, and since she is a great mother he didn't have the heart to take them away from her for even a few days at a time when they were little. That's why I think he agreed to have joint custody on paper but in reality, visitation is at her house. (The ex also went to the same vacation spots a few times as him when they were little --I put a stop to this when he met me-- cause she couldn't bare to not share in anything they experienced(gag me!) Also, he didn't have the money to even have a place that could accomodate 3 kids! I guess he kept it simple...But, now they are older, circumstances are different and it sickens me to think that he doesn't feel he is worthy enough to get them more than he does. I feel like we are second class citizens. She has them every Thanksgiving, New Years, or actually anytime she wants. I want to start alternating! He lets them make the rules...he never makes waves. He's a great, sacrificing father but not thinking of our side of the family now. I know it's his kids,he can decide what to do and that's what i tell myself butI feel sorry for my 12 yr old daughter because she loves having stepsiblings, even though she only sees them now one weekend a month. I wish we had 50/50 and not to save money in child support but because I do love the kids and love seeing him with his children. Very heartwarming.
Some Pros and Cons
I have been doing a lot of research on this issue. Research can only document past incidences and draw general conclusions; every situation is different. But I think it is a good starting point. I have found that academically there are two different perspectives. One perspective is that it is hugely beneficial to children to have as frequent and continuing contact with EACH parent as possible. Each parent brings different family histories, daily rituals, values and principles that are key to the children's development, and the only way to really soak those things up is to have something more than "weekend" or "holiday" downtime. The child needs to have each parent interact with their friends, help with homework, participate in sports activities; the child needs to see each parent at their best and their worst; at Disneyland AND at the grocery store. There are many studies documenting the benefits to children of 50/50 time when there are healthy families on each side of the equation and some level of co-parenting. On the other hand, there are some folks who suggest that 50/50 is detrimental because it never really allows children to feel "at home" in one place, to get routines down without interruption and because they may receive different messages from each home. There are much fewer studies that I have found documenting these disadvantages. It seems to me that many of these "problems" could be solved with active parenting/co-parenting in the best interests of the children.
No I am not writing a book--it's just that research is usually my first step toward problem solving and making decisions in my own life. It's not for everyone but it's just how I do things.
In my own experience, I was raised by my mom with sole custody and my dad with holiday visitation. I only really got to know my dad in the last ten-15 years (I am 36). I think I lost out big time, esp. now that I am older and realize the emotional consequences of not having my real dad around, and esp. watching DH with my skids.
(Have any other posters *experienced* custody arrangement themselves? I think sharing our own experiences is a relevant question because that goes to how the *kid* feels, instead of a parent trying to interpret how a kid feels -- does that make sense?)
Also, my brothers who are ten years younger than me were on a 50/50 schedule between my mom and their dad, and to this day they say that is how they preferred it, they loved seeing both parents equally, having two homes, two sets of toys, two neighborhoods of friends, etc. and never felt interrupted by the transition (the two families lived in the same town).
My skids thus far seem to be on the same page as my brothers, based on their comments about how much they love having two homes and such big families, so many people to love. They want more weekend time at their mom's and more weekday time with their dad, which is what we want too. Both families live in the town, and are "relatively" well-adjusted in the co-parenting thing, and in my opinion that makes all the difference as to how well a 50/50 arrangement works. For what that's worth.
I was also raised by my mom
My parents split when I was 8, and I think I am one of those exceptions to the rule: I was actually kind of relieved that they got divorced. Not that my dad was necessarily abusive, but he was really tough on us kids and he was always shaming us and we just generally didn't have a good relationship with him. It was just "easier" to be with mom and not have to deal with him on a daily basis.
When my parents divorced, we left our home in Nova Scotia Canada and came back to the states where my parents' families were. My mom and we three kids moved in with my grandmother in rural Maryland until we bought a house nearby, and my dad moved back to the DC area where he could find work. So we lived 2 hours apart and did the eow schedule for a few years.
Things started getting sticky when I entered middle school and adolescence and every time I had to miss a slumber party or a dance because it landed on dad's weekend, I was pretty resentful like any preteen when I had to miss out. (I was too afraid of hurting dad's feelings to ask him to let me stay at mom's.) I wished he just lived in our town so I wouldn't have to live two separate lives, but it was so rural, there was no work for him there.
So, when my dad announced when I was 11 or 12 that he was moving to Florida, part of me was like "thank GOD!" Of course, the other part of me felt abandoned, but my friends were so important to me at that age, I just focused on not having to miss out on social activities anymore. I remember he justified his move as he only sees us 52 days a year on the eow schedule, so now we'll see each other the same number of days over the summer and every other Christmas. Yeah, I know, not the same as regular contact, but that's how he justified it.
The 50/50 thing would have never worked with us. My dad just didn't know how to be a good parent. He is very rigid and we never felt good enough - I'm still dealing with self-esteem issues because of the way he treated me! Even to this day, instead of saying something like "honey, I'm proud of you for buying your first house on your own at age 25," he'll say "why didn't you get in 3 years ago before the bubble?!" Well, let's see Dad, I was a grad student with no income at age 22. There was no way I could have bought a freakin' house! Still, whatever I do, it's not enough for him and somehow I still beat myself up over things because of his putting me down! I'm 29 now and still feel like an ashamed little girl when he gets started on me.
Anyway, I think that being with my mom the vast majority of the time really helped me keep my sanity! She reminds me that I am a success, and not to worry about not living up to my dad's impossible expectations. I think living in a 50/50 arrangement would have done even more irreparable damage... Just my experience. I think the dads here seeking more equitable custody aren't like my dad, so this probably doesn't apply at all to your situations!
I don't know... now that I'm really thinking about it, part of me thinks like Gwen that I really did miss out big time by not having regular contact with my dad. Maybe things would've been better if he had seen us more often and really "knew" us? Hard to tell at this stage. Maybe if we could have lived in the same town, things would've been different. Wow, this is digging up a lot of emotions!!
Hi Caitlin
Thank you for sharing your story with us. It sounds as though it was very hard.
I guess right now we are trying to determine what is best for my Sd as well as for the family. We live only five mintues away from the ex (yuck) so that we can be available any time SD needs us. We bought this house for that reason.
Hearing from all situations is good. I do think our situation is differnt because my Dh wants every minute he can get with his daugther. He misses her at the end of every visit and can't wait for the next one. She is an amazing little BIG sister. Our son loves her...walks around the house with her picture kissing it...too cute.
If your dad was different and lived in the same city do you think it would have make it better for you to be with him more? I always think us girls need soemthing from our dads that our mom's can't give us. They are the first men that we love. I hope you can look inside yourself and know that you are a success..whatever dad didn't give you you got it from your mom and yourself. It sounds like you have done well. Be proud of yourself.
Yes, girls need their dads!
Wow, writing all that down really stirred up some thoughts that I haven't paid much mind to over the years. Now, with an adult perspective, I think I can honestly say that if my dad had lived in the same town and had more daily interaction with us, that we all would have benefitted from it, even if he hadn't been any different. (If he had been easier to get along with, it would be a no brainer!) As a selfish little kid I preferred him living far away because I wanted to be with my friends - but kids need both their parents! I really didn't think about that at the time. That just goes to show you that kids don't always know what's best for themselves! Plus, I knew that him living in our town was just never an option, so I never really entertained the idea.
Anyway, I totally hear you about the amazing big sister thing too. My SD and daughter have such an amazing bond! Do you know that my daughter walks around the house with SD's picture kissing it too?! I love it! So not only do kids need both their parents, they also need regular interaction and bonding time with the rest of their family members. SD gets very sad missing her baby sister. I so wish that we could live in SD's town. We actually considered it, but it would be an hour and 15 minute commute for me, and the area is extremely expensive. We really couldn't have afforded anything more than a 2 bedroom and with this growing family, that is not enough room! We only live 20 miles away, but it can take 30-50 minutes, depending on traffic.
SD often shares with me that her dream is to live in a duplex with her mom on one side and us on the other and her bedroom on the third floor with access to both sides of the house. How cute is she? She just wants regular access to all her loved ones. If we could do 50/50, we would. I know that everyone (with the exception of BM, of course) would benefit from it. I hope it will work out for you!
We will go for it. I agree
We will go for it. I agree it is worth the fight. She won't give it to us easily....hope she makes me eat those words.
I am just not sure what way works best..one week on one week off, break the days down like you did..so that if you enroll them into a sport..say it is on Mondays, you are able to always take them. I know that we have decided we will house all the necessary things for her here...clothes, toiletries etc (she is only 5 she we can do it right now) so she doesn't have to carry a suitcase to school. All drop offs and pick ups are done at the school so they don't have to see each other (only during holidays).
It is just a shame that you have to fight for what should be yours already...takes two to make a baby. The courts should start at 50% if both parties want it that way and then work backwards if they have. "God giveth and God taketh it away"...something like that.
It's Worth Trying
We have 50/50. Friday to Friday, so the kids have the weekend to settle in (transition) and not iterfere with school. The biggest problem is that the other half of the 50/50 has waaaay different rule , or should I say no rules. I have 3 kids and 100% less EOW/HOLIDAY , therefore I have never been confused as to whether I am a parent or friend and carry no guilt for the divorce (divorced 11 yrs). My Ex stays out of the discipline-- he is the fun one. Did/does it bother me? YES. Until my 19 yr old said she knows that I am the one she can depend on (beaming). On the other hand my DH and his EX still have residual anger after 10yrs of divorce, use the kids to communicate and compete for the favored parent. DRIVES ME NUTS!!! My DH and I are in co-parenting classes. DH and SD are in therapy (SD has a lot of anxiety & self esteem issues). And BM??? she wants no part of it---and she neeeeds it. Oh Well it is an investment in our future, some day SD will realize the BM is NOT the victim of DH, but of her own choices.
If you are seriously considering this type of placement, I would recommend to the courts that you want co-parenting classes for BM &BD and you and her SO if applicable. The courts will recognize this as mature and may even side with you by requiring it. Because the variances of discipline is probably the biggest hurdle. It is the best scenario if the bio-parents can do it right, put aside their differences for the good of raising children... HMMMMM sounds so easy. NOT!!!! For example this weekend DH is out of town, SD is with BM. SD has a competition that she must participate in for a grade, but doesn't like to. I get a call from the teacher today that she didn't show up. ( The teachers always call here because we are home base and attend all conferences, games, competitions , etc. NOT BM) If history is an indicator... she told mom she was sick mom said awwww and she didn't have to go. Mom obviously did not call the teacher to say she was ill--so no call no show. (boads well for a graded assignment) IF DH was here and it was our wkend, she would have gone.. she has the same cold that all 6 of has/had and still met our obligations.
Sometimes the dads do win....
I do think each situation is different...Wait until you hear this one! I married my husband a couple of years ago (my 1st marriage, his 2nd)& he has joint custody of his two daughters (at the time of the divorce were only 3 and 7). While it's joint custody, he is the primary custodian. They live with us most of the time...then every other weekend from Thurs after school until Mon dropoff at school they are with their bio-mother. Some holidays etc...but he didn't have to fight too much in court...she really didn't want to have them so she signed off on the agreement (before I entered the picture)...
Once he married me we spent a lot of time and $ in court. She wouldn't follow the rules of the divorce, was abusive toward him, me, the kids.... but in the end SHE now has to pay a little child support. I know - times are changing!
On the flip side I have a bio-daughter who was raised without a father (until I married my husband when she was 12). In this situation her bio-dad didn't want to be a "dad"...my college boyfriend, young etc.. so I didn't force the issue. Got a lawyer, had him sign away his rights and I waived any child support from him. Between my parents, brother, extended family she is now the most compassionate teenager, straight A student and I couldn't be more proud of her.
Times are changing - if you want more custody, GO FOR IT! It's hard work - I've seen both sides; a bio-dad never meeting his daughter to a bio-mom only wanting limited custody for "show" so she doesn't look bad. Point is...KIDS COME FIRST. DO WHAT'S IN YOUR HEART...
From both a Stepmom and Biomom
Tyra...
ours is 50/50, not working. we see ss only 8x a month, wednesdays and every other weekend. not enought time, how can they say that's 50/50 custody. it's bullshit! biomom controls all aspect of decision making without consulting w/father first. then we are suppose to split vacation equally but that not how it is right now. we are both irritated w/her we don't want to take her back to court cause she'll ask for more money. we have 8 more years of putting up w/her and after that we are getting rid of her bullshit.
-happy mom
well
well........................................................................................................................................
Apparently everyone has the wrong view of my situation, or you all really don't give a sh*t. Just because I have a comfortable living doesn't mean that I didn't contriibute. I DO have a college degree and had a VERY successful career. We had virtually No money when we got married. My ex made 23,000 a year. I chose to stay home, buy second hand clothes for my daughter, grabbed furniture from neighbors garbage and repainted it, or whatever was needed. We only had a refrigerator in the basement which I had to go up and down the stairs 9 months pregnant. We were robbed the first week we lived in our new home. Came home from work early and there was one of 4 robbers waiting around the corner for me with a 7" gutter nail.
I do not frequent saks, I do not have furs, I own not one piece of
Tiffanys' and all this free time you speak of, where is it???????????
My ex has, a majority of our kids lives, been absent. I am sick of defending myself as NONE of you know what it is like. My ex walked out on me and the kids not once but twice for another woman. Could you imagine???????????????????????????????????????????????????
I promise I hurt just as much as anyone else. And I promise just because my kids are well taken care of financially, they hurt even more because the virtually have NO FATHER. He is on to his new woman.
Enjoy your glass houses.
No glass house hear...
I have experience your past and it isn't nice. Fortunately I had my career to fall back on and am now far more successful than my ex. Poetic justice!
Thanks
Thanks
I appreciate your support. I think I am done with this site. Too many hostile women for me. I was hoping to get some insight to the world of the stepmother. All I got was some nasty judgements. I hope you come out of this with some helpfull advice.
The best to you and your family
Bettyboop, don't base your decision to leave...
On a few comments as not everyone feels this way. I totally support you and understand %100 what you are saying. No two situations are alike. There are men on this site that I wouldn't give five cents for...but every coat has a hanger. I am not into fixer-uppers and I commend you for thriving in spite of the challenges that you faced. So stick around if it feels right...just watch what you post cuz their is some hostile stuff that happens once in a while...you're not the only one who has bitter feelings. So relax and celebrate you and the changes that you have made in your life!