On the good news my husband is finally getting counseling for PTSD having to pull his best friend and brother out from under a drunk drivers car that hit him while walking with husband. sD is still using the situation to get what she wants. However puppy is becoming a dog, and people are less likely to overcome a dogs bad behavior therefore she is having to deal with that. She is flunking her classes, still trying to blame always the teachers. I have commented to husband that the way she trains( not) her dog is not any way his brother or us trained our pets. She is all about drugging it up when with family and a shock collar( little actaul guidance) and kennelling so she can go out as it whines . I am honestly waiting for her to graduate move and say finally the dog is too much sonthatbwe can love it. Honestly her treatment of the dog makes me ill. Like insaid my husband is finally in counseling and he is after only a couple sessions starting to show positive changes in our relationship. I pray that as this goes on he is less led astray by his daughters manipulative behavior to get what she thinks she wants. I just wish that she could in all her obvious insecurity see that she can stop competing and putting people down to make herself feel better. I pray for her introspection.