Need some reassurance
My husband married me when my bio daughter was almost 9 years old. Her bio father had pretty much abandoned her when she was between 3 and 4 years old. He paid no child support, other than a few months in the beginning of our divorce. My amazing new husband loved me and took on my daughter, 100%. He helped put her through private school, braces and the whole bit. He tried to plan fun things for us to do together. Mind you, he never had been a father before (he was 32 years old when we got married) and hadn't ever held a baby or had any real interaction with kids. My hubby is a very reserved person (or shy or introverted), as the daughter aged I can now look back and see they really drifted apart. Bio dad would pop into the picture every once in awhile for a phone call 2-4 times a year. Now daughter is 21 years old and has these claims of being abused by my husband's lack of words or emotional connection. I've tried reasoning with her but calls my reasoning "excuses". Daughter has also rekindled with her bio dad over the last couple of years and lives in the same town as him, across the country from us. Does anyone have any words of advice for us. Some say my husband should apologize..even though it's not necessary. Course, I did say, hubby is really shy and talking isn't his best suit. It makes me so sad that she doesn't understand all that he did for her and even though she wasn't able to bond emotionally with my hubby, she had it very good. She now says stuff like she wonders how our kids together (ages 8 and 11) will fair the way he is. I personally think it's completely a different story, cause I don't think anyone could really fill the huge shoes that were left by her ridiculous bio dad. She's forgiven her bio dad..what's up with being so hard on the guy that didn't have to do a darn thing for her in the first place, but did?
Any words of encouragement or advice is greatly appreciated!
Peace.
I don't think your husband
I don't think your husband needs to apologize for anything, he did what he could to give her a good life. Over and beyond what he needed to considering she is not his bio. Sounds to me your daughter needs to get over herself and apologize to him.
I think things will be ok. My
I think things will be ok. My DH is the only father my daughter has has since age 7. While he is affectionate with me, as far as both his own and mine, he never initiated any affection, but if and when they wanted to hug him, he obviously treasured every second of it. He just isn't a pushy, lovey dovey kind of dad. It upset me for a while, but he has been a consistent figure in her life, never questioned money, never made her feel like she did nit belong. It has not been perfect and now DD is very curious about her dad and now and then brings him up.
Maybe your daughter thinks she betrayed her dad and now has to pick an allegiance. Hopefully she will get past this and realize the value of this relationship.
As hard as it us, I would try and just be there, let her know she is entitled to her feelings, but also point out how as far as step parents, she has been very lucky. She would benefit from a lot of the conversations here, where no one is under the illusion that a step is loved unconditionally just like a biological child. What she has received may not be the entire package one hopes to get from a dad, but it is nothing to scoff at.
Be there for your husband, for whom this must be very hard.
I sure wish you the best. Hang in there. Sometimes young adults process their anger a little late and cause a lot of pain in their wake.
They say its easier to
They say its easier to forgive a bio parent than a step parent and that a step parent is an *easier* object to blame and push all the issues on. Sounds like this is what has happened here.
Your daughter obviously missed the emotional connection between her and her SD, and at 21 is too immature and shortsighted to realise that everyone is different, that you should accept people for who they are and be grateful for the things you did receive. Her re-connection and possibly affectionate relationship with her bio dad has underlined the fact she has missed out on being "daddy's little girl" and she is left perhaps thinking there was something wrong with her, that for some reason your DH rejected her.
It seems to me he didnt. I think personally you cant force your DD to change her mind, certainly you can put your own point of view across about this and I would say I wouldnt want to hear the negative commentary regarding how your other children will fair with your DH as their dad. Personally I would say when she says things like that: "I dont think thats nice. You are forgetting who was there for you when you were younger- he didnt have to support us and provide for us. Dont blame your SD because you didnt that close father-daughter relationship,that is something you BD is to blame for - where was he? SD has been and still is good to you and you need to except that he isnt a demonstrative man or at least stop bad mouthing him. These are your issues, so own them...." then shut down any convo's going in that direction. Pointless trying to reason when she isnt prepared to listen.
I would be ashamed of her disrespect tbh and would show her this.
I feel for you and what you
I feel for you and what you are dealing with right now. What IO can say is that I have 2 adult bios and 2 adult steps and ALL 4 have done the same. Even the one daughter I am closest to. I have been in counseling now for 7 months trying to deal with all of this. It is hard and it hurts like I never imagined a hurt could from a child. Infact, I have a post on here about "Why poeple feel they can tell me what you do?" explaining what I am going thru right now.
My counselor sayd that adult children reach a point in their adult years where they feel like they have taken on their adult lives and feel they have direction but really they are only trying to spread their wings and are actually very insecure. In the process they reflect on a childhood and the blame game begins. Counselor said all children come to their adult years wounded from their childhood, all have parent tapes, all feel abandoned and unloved bnut unfortunately they are the ones who have to find themselves and figure it out for themselves. We can be supportive but that we should never get into the specifics and the tit for tat stuff. She said some will hold grudges the rest of their lives and will never get past the feeling of hurt and blame for the parent. That has been terribly sad for me to realize I have poured so much of my heart and soul into my entire family and I feel I have lost them all to something that seems almost evil.
Can we say "victim
Can we say "victim mentality?"
My own daughter pulled this crap on me when she was about 20. The fact that we even have a relationship after the incredibly horrible rebellous teenage years is a miricle.
So what did I do? I did apologize to her for all of these imagined slights. But I also told her that was the last apology she would hear from me on the subject. So we've moved on.
My Dad beat the hell out of me on a regular basis and I would never in a million years have confronted him as an adult on the issue.
Thanks so much for your
Thanks so much for your inputs. It really breaks my heart that my daughter cannot see what a blessing she has had. I'm really hoping it's just her selfish 21 year old brain and maybe with some time and maturing she'll understand how much my husband (she did call him dad)did for us. Even if all he did was support me to be a better mom and not be so stressed out, and didn't even try to do "fatherly" things for her, she is still way ahead of the game, and he did far more! She really thinks she's been abused and I'm sure her childhood wasn't the picture she wanted of being that Daddy's girl. That picture was destroyed when her bio dad decided "he wasn't the married type anymore" when she was three years old. I wrote her a brief note today and encouraged her to work through these feelings. I also told her I wished that life wasn't so messy and that I could have protected her from all of life's hurts. I'm sure she really feels them and I am really sorry for that.
Even though I don't think my husband is the cause, like Delilah said earlier, she really wanted to be Daddy's Girl and blaming it on my sweet husband for not being her daddy, when her step father was doing what he was capable of. I don't want to make her feel like she can't feel her emotions, so name it and get to work on it. Hopefully maybe someone will be able to help her understand that most of her angst is coming from her bio father. She's not a bad kid, she's on her own and pays her own way. I am really hoping this can be worked through. I know it's not my husband's fault but if he could find a way to say something really simple someday (not that I think he HAS to but it might help) like, "I'm sorry that we weren't able to connect in the way that you would have liked. But, I do love you and I want you to know that." I think those words could really help her, but it's got to be his thing. I'm not going to whine about it. To me, that's all it might take. Then like a PP said, it's over..get on with life. Look forward, not back.