Anyone Ever Left A Blended Family Then Returned?
I was recently asked in May by my partner after 5 years of blended living, and 6.5 years of dating, to move out 'for the summer, then see what happens.' The problems in our relationship came down to differences in parenting, how her middle child behaved towards me, and how I reacted to said child. The oldest and youngest of her three kids had no issues with me. And I was pretty hands-off most of the time never really trying to be anyone's father or parent them, just rudimentary requests like, please wash hands, pick up your trash, turn off lights you left on, put your dishes in dishwasher, etc. I also have a high-functioning autistic teen son that was coexisting with her three kids, but rarely engaged by or engaged with them, especially the middle one. After an obvious trend by middle child, now 17, it became apparent that she has issues. I believe no matter who my partner had chosen, the same thing would have happened to them, a smear campaign, devaluation, and many forms of triangulation. I invested so much emotionally, financially, and physically to blended living. When deciding to live together, I made the decision to retain my home, and my partner sold the house she purchased with her ex, and bought a new one not far from the old one for all six of us to live in. The plan was to use both the new blended home, and my home an hour away occasionally. My kiddo got to go from a top 200 school, to a top 10 school. Our ten year plan was after the last kiddo finishes high-school we would sell blended family home then either move back to my home full-time, or sell that one and buy a new one near my home, an area she liked well enough.
After about 4 years of biting my tongue with middle kid, then 15, I had then had enough when she made a show in front of a friend of hers by insulting and disrespecting me. I had let it slide since the friend was there and left the house to go to the gym. After a good workout and lots of thought, I came home and still did not feel right about it. My partner had acknowledged on previous occasions that her kids behavior was inappropriate, yet in a way expected me to roll with it. At times I even felt like she downplayed events, and made excuses for behaviors, like her kids poor mental health. It at times felt a little gas lighty. So, after being a canary in a coal mine to my partner for so long, I took it upon myself to tell middle kid off. It felt liberating, yet I was not proud of it because she ended up crying to her mother. My partner understood at the time and tried to talk to her kid about it. The middle kids attitude didn't change, and she progressively became more entitled and off-putting, struggling to keep or make friends. I felt bad for her, but soon after disengaged from her. We didn't talk to one another for about 7 months, until one day on vacation she swam out to me in the ocean because her sister was uncomfortable swimming that far out. We must have been a good mile from shore as the water wasn't that deep. It was somewhat awkward, but I saw it as an opportunity to build some trust and create common ground. After about an hour we swam back to shore. I later found out my partner, her other two kids, and my aunt had all placed bets jokingly which one of us would return to shore. It only took about 2 hrs for middle kid to revert back to her old self towards me. She even started texting her sister negative things about me on the way home later that weekend.
About a year later we had a second blow up. I had asked her to clean some hair out of the shower tub if it belonged to her (which I knew it did.) We had paid our plumber already three times $175 to snake the tub drain. I felt like as a providing adult, I should be able to make preventative requests to all four kids. The only one who ever took issue with many forms of resistance was middle kid. So, the tub request turned into a heated debate. My partner came in to intervene but middle kids demeanor and insults toward me was too much. I was weak and ended up hitting a wall. It came out of nowhere. I felt so awful and ashamed. I made every effort to make it right with everyone in the house. I even started looking for a therapist. Something middle kid would not commit to for herself thinking her problems where the world around her and not herself. My partner asked me to move out then thinking we all needed space, so I cordially agreed. The problem was that my home was in flux with no heating or cooling, under remediation due to a contractors error, and it was the middle of February. I took my kiddo to his paternal grandmother's (no relation to me) and I went to stay in my 28 degree home. After pleading with my partner for 2 days to work things out, not just because my pipes were frozen, but because how much I genuinely wanted to make things work, she let me come back. She started therapy immediately, while I struggled to find a therapist due to insurance and availability of therapists, but eventually found one a few weeks later.
The strain on our relationship was apparent starting in 2023. I was dealing with so much with the loss of my home, my mother and sister, trying to parent my autistic adopted son (bio nephew), and the death by 1000 cuts poor demeaning behavior towards me from day 1 by partner's middle child. I felt like my partner invalidated my pain gradually saying I took her daughters behavior too personal and that I stopped giving her attention and affection, which I didn't intend or want to happend. And she felt like she wasn't meeting my parenting needs. She had in February during the blow up with her middle kid, told the kid how good of a partner I had been to her taking on three kids, and all that I have done for everyone.
It's been three months now separated. School starts in three weeks. I may need to enroll my kid in his old school district from 6 years ago for his last year of high school. He is so crushed. He misses his friends and the better school. I really miss my partner. I wanted to marry her, and she wanted me to marry her, but we both knew her middle kid was not ready for that. Partner was even sending me photos of rings she liked back in November, pre-Feb blow up with her kid. I feel like I've been robbed of my soul mate, or maybe I haven't? A month ago I texted her a list of everything I was willing to do to make it work for everyone, acknowledging her middle kid would possibly never come around. My partner responded she needed to think about it and that it was a lot to process. She said she needed space and time to sort herself out. It has been a really difficult summer for me and my son. My partner and I are still connected on social media (I stopped posting, but she looks happy with kids,) and we still share a Google calendar. Whether or not she had unchecked mine to not see what I'm up to or not, she has not removed or restricted from hers. I turn another year older tomorrow. I'm not expecting gifts from anyone, nor do I want any. But I'm so anxious about the potential of not hearing from her tomorrow. If not, it may solidify the real potential that it's over, and I need to move on. Time will heal I suppose. Just wondering if anyone else has been in a similar situation. Was there ever a way back? If so, did things improve after reconciliation? Thanks.
Havent been there, but....
I haven't been in that situstion but if I had been, I wouldn't have gone back, knowing what I do now. I had 3 SKs, too, the boys were ok but SDnow62 is, and always has been, a big problem. You can read my blogs and see that at 79, she is still negatively affecting my life.
You sound like a kind, thoughtful person. I can tell you really miss your SO and you're aware of time passing and are, perhaps, concerned you'll never find another partner. I also understand your issues about your son's schooling.
Some ideas: thank heavens you still have your house. How about just "dating" her for a couple years and see what happens? Can you keep your son enrolled in the good school by paying out-of-district tuition for the last year?
A couple red flags for both of you: Hitting that wall was bad on your part. As a mom, I would have had worries. I kind of understand your SO's idea of separating you from the daughter for awhile. But to know you're sleeping in an unheated house in 28 degree weather is not what a caring person does.
Whatever happens, good luck and hapoy birthday.
Thank You
I've thought about just dating her a year or so ago when I used to fantasize about leaving because of the middle kid, although during arguments with my SO I had threatened to leave. She would often say I had one foot in and one foot out. I never left and was fully committed to her. She knew and still knows this, as she was to me, but is the type of parent that puts their kids above all else. Some believe the marriage, or partnership is the foundation of a family. I'm not sure she agrees. She did let me come back after two days when it was cold. Now that it's summer, she has said in one message that she had wanted this to happen in February, so she's taking that time for herself now. She is definitely at a cross roads in regards to our relationship, and I can understand. I'm sorry about your older step daughter. That was and is sort of my fear with the middle daughter. She is the most like her biological father, who is manic and bipolar, and self medicates with hard liquor. Not that she is drinking now, but has poked at her mom saying how she can't wait to start drinking, naming different drinks. I've watched her mom entertain the idea passively as to almost not completely shut her down. The term gentle parenting does not do it justice. Yes, I regret hitting the wall in that moment. Her kids know I would never hurt them, as I don't have a reputation or history with violence. My partner knows as much or else she would never have trusted me to be left me alone with them. Even the youngest who used to climb on me and wrestle explicitly said, I know you would never hurt me. During the move out my partner made it a point to not be there all 5 or 6 times it took me to move my belongings out. Each time the kids were there doing their thing. Perhaps I should sort myself out and move on. My confidence is at an all-time low. I miss her so much.
People don't change much
I'm not saying a bratty teen can't change. But this girl has some hereditary issues. My SD as a teen was self-centered and entitled and that hasn't changed. I see your SO's daughter retaining her traits as an adult. In other words, don't think "at 18, it's over". If you go back, accept that you'll be dealing with her forever.
What exactly do you see as
What exactly do you see as improving if you return? her daughter has now been able to oust you from the home and get her mom to dance to her tune. she will be emboldened, she will make it her life's goal to goad you into a reaction. And her mom will let her.
Don't you think you deserve better than that? doesn't your son?
Yes, you're right
I do deserve better. I suppose I'm hoping the therapy my SO has been in is helping her with her weaker parenting? Or just bigger picture things in general? I dunno? Balance between her kids and her relationship with me? She will have to strike a balance regardless if she commits to me or eventually meets someone else.
With what you have
With what you have experienced being her victim, what makes you think her X was the problem in that failed family?
My bet is that, based on your description of her and her crap, she was the problem.
Her X is lucky to have escaped.
You should follow his example.
The reality is that she
The reality is that she already was allowing her child to dictate your relationship.. you both would have been married.. but child was the issue. I mean.. if it was a case of you both wanted to wait until all the kids had aged out of the home before combining homes.. that is one thing. but it seems like the middle girl was allowed to completely hijack things.
Generally, I think that when things are pushed to extremes.. like you hitting the wall.. that's a clear sign that the level of stress and dysfunction in that home was too much and that it wasn't going to be healthy for you to stay. Because prior to hitting the wall.. you would have never thought you would do something like that.. next it could be you striking one of the kids in anger.. or your SO.. because the level of toxicity is making you into a person that you aren't.
Thank you for your insight. I
Thank you for your insight. I believe because of their situation and my partner having to make the difficult choice of removing their father, she eventually started parenting out of guilt.
I absolutely would never strike anyone. No matter how angry or resentful I became. I don't condone violence, especially in the family circle.
One thing that I was warned by a family member was to be wary of the kid fabricating a lie about me. Something eluding to me acting inappropriately. She one time about three years ago responded to her mother when asked, 'why don't you like him?' Her ridiculous response to her mother, 'you won't like it when you find out.' Such a shame. I slaved away on that house and over invested.
I was just going to warn you
I was just going to warn you about this, but I see you said it in a reply.
"One thing that I was warned by a family member was to be wary of the kid fabricating a lie about me. Something eluding to me acting inappropriately."
I think at this point you do have choices.
1. find a new abode for you and your son & date your partner away from her daughter.
2. go back and the odds of you being accused of abuse loom large. remember, middle kid knows how to work her mom, it's only a matter of time and it will destroy your life.
3. accept that you tried your best, but it just isn't going to work. call it quits, walk away and work on yourself w/ a therapist. Then get back out into the world where you can meet new people and find new interests.
Honestly, it's high risk with
Honestly, it's high risk with a kid who is troubled like that. If you wanted to maintain any relationship.. it would have to be in separate homes.. and possibly if the daughter grows up .. moves out.. matures.. maybe, just maybe there would be a chance.
But.. I always like to say that Relationships aren't easy.. but they shouldn't be THAT hard. We all have normal trials and tribulations... growing pains and setbacks to deal with.. but when you feel there is a mountain to move.. maybe it's just trying to make the wrong thing happen.. especially when you realize that for every shovel of dirt you move.. others are replacing it double.
I don't think you should move back in, if you want to keep the
I don't think you should remove back in, if you want to keep the relationship, just date. This girl is only going to get worse. She now understands her power and while you and your SO are in therapy the girl should also be in therapy. I agree with what was said upthread, if she gets mad, all she needs to do is place one call to the authorities to completely ruin your life. She could also decide to go after your son. The risk is not worth it.
I am worried that your son has to switch schools again, is there anyway you can keep him in the school he has been in?
Hard to say what would happen
Hard to say what would happen. I think she is more manipulative. Unlikely she would go after my son as she understands his needs albeit not very sympathetic to him. I am unsure what the district will say, as I will approach them early next week, maybe sooner. He is IEP, and you would think my 'people before things' partner would have a heart. I feel like I was just a stepping stone. Managing two homes was brutal, and I definitely put more work and money into our blended family home, or her legal home. Interesting she said early this summer after she kicked me out was, 'it feels like you prioritized your home over me in countless ways over the years.' I tried to reassure her that was not the intention or case. Makes me wonder what type of person I am dealing with. No closure from her yet, just 3 weeks ago, 'I'm not trying ignore you, this is a lot, I need time to process.' I've realized I may need to create my own closure if reconciliation is not in the stars.
You have only one choice.
You have only one choice. Protect your son from this cesspool of failed family genetics led by your X. She is your X. Keep it that way.
"Hard to tell what would happen...." Not really. Whatever happens it will not be good for your son or for you. Stop being the beck and call boy/chore bitch/ATM for this nightmare of disfunction and put your time into creating the best life possible for you and your son and into getting your own home/house in order. Her house can fall down. And... sue her for your time and investment in her house. Force the sale if you can, get your money out of it, and move on.
And for damned sure if you decide to keep sleeping with her, get clipped before you screw up your life permanently.
So, it appears your need to
So, it appears you need to get your house in order literally. Stop waiting for her to decide about moving you back in and start working on your home and making it livable for you and your son. Get him enrolled in school and help him start making that transition. I understand a breakup is hard, but it appears perhaps your SO has found peace after all these years and isn’t ready to give it back up. Time for you to start finding your own peace and moving on.
Yes, I've been working on my
Yes, I've been working on my home all summer while emotionally being a mess. My son is my priority once again.
If the BF was bipolar
Then most likely SD is bipolar. Two different personalities. You can't deal with a bipolar person.
'Where does this leave you. Not is a good place because GF is buying into all of this.
One can handle the bipolar kid by keeping her in her place. But once GF started taking the crazy person side all reason is lost.
'You have to make a exit plan. First of all you are already gone but dont realize it. You moved out in February, 6 months ago. And not in a better place now.
'Make plans with your DS with out GF Get your house fixed up to live in it. Winter is a few months away
You have been with your gf
You have been with your gf for a signigicant amount of years.
As time has ticked along, things have become worse NOT better.
Time to cut sling load and focus on your minor child who needs YOU.
I have to ask, are you helping her financially? In any way?
As difficult as it is you are
As difficult as it is you are right. No, I'm not supporting her financially, but I've invested probably 15k into her home over the past 6.5 yrs, where she probably invested 1k into my home, all figured in from our joint account which now has a zero balance. We took out a 20k loan 3 years ago from our bank for all new windows in the blended family home. With 13k left, I am the primary signer, and she is listed as a co-signer. She was super eager and I went with it on good faith and love. When my legal home needed a new HVAC and a water system she passively dug her heels in. Shame how this all went down. She earns more than me, so I am hoping she'll pay the remaining balance on her new windows.
Big ooof
Unless you are on the deed, you should NEVER invest money (or much sweat equity) into a home. Mowing the lawn - yes. Ripping out an old deck and building a new one - no.
You already GF already
Gave her DD the keys to the kingdom, it's hard to go back. It was much easier to stop this in the beginning. Now you have a real problem. GF doesn't see it. GF Picked DD over you. Just forget about the money. You should look for a new relationship now when you still have time.
'Knowing any relationship will have kids. It's how they handle there kids. I hear your situation is not that uncommon. The mother gives her her kids husban status. BF/ DH gets to follow kids control off family
Never go back. This is a
Never go back. This is a coward breakup from her. Don't play her games.
Rent a place for you and your HS Sr. to live for his HS Sr. year while you get your home in order and put this coward partner and her failed family middle spawn in your rear view mirror.
You nor your son can live your best lives while you wallow in the effluent of this shallow and polluted gene pool of a failed family.
Someone with no soul is incapable of being the soul mate of anyone of quality. That is an incontestable truth. Stop wasting your time. Stop sacrificing yourself and your own son on the alter of Sparental martyrdom to this tragically flawed shit storm of a failed partner, failed parent, and failed family.
IMHO of course.
Good luck.
Take care of you.