The main event
This next part of my story is the beginning of my blended family's collapse. In happened on Easter in 2022. First, a little bit of background about my mother, who unfortunately, was a key player. My mother is 78. Her own mother died when she was 12, and she was the primary caregiver in the year leading up to her death. Her father was busy working and cheating on her mother. Her sister, who was 8 years older, had married and moved out of the house. Following her mother's death, her father quickly remarried. The SM had no love or compassion for my mother and she was severely neglected. In time, my mother moved in with an aunt and then with her sister. But the damage was done. My mom has come a very long way from those days, but a part of her will always live in that trauma, and she has the emotional maturity of that broken 12 year old girl. It's hard for me to write this. As a child, I didn't understand all of these pieces and I've had a lot of resentment about my own childhood. My mother would, and has, done anything for me. But she still has the emotional maturity of a 12 year old, and the social maturity to match. Over the Trump administration years (we're in Canada) my mother spent a lot of time focussed on what was happening in the US. Truthfully, many of us Canadians did, She loved Obama and was hopeful that the first female president would be next. My occupation requires a lot of continuing education on equity and diversity, and my children, as young adults in university, are very interested and engaged in discussion on equity and diversity. We've had many discussions around the dinner table about these issues and my mother is eager to be part of them and to understand. But... she's 78 and emotionally immature. And she's largely unaware of her predisposed biases and prejudices. My family is white. My parents immigrated to Canada from Portugal as young adults.
My SD's DH's family is from Guyana. I don't believe anyone in my family or my DH's family ever had a second thought about his background (although I do know that despite our best efforts, we're all steeped in unconscious bias).
We hosted brunch on Easter 2022. My extended family was there, as well as my MIL and my SD and her DH. Everyone knows eachother quite well, and everyone knows that my mother can be counted on to say something inappropriate. She did not disappoint. During pre-brunch discussion, she began asked who the "brown people" are. I'm cringing as a write this and I am so sorry to any readers it offends. She said that she doesn't understand what people mean when they refer to "brown people" and said that when she immigrated, people like her with Mediterranean backgrounds were sometimes referred to as being brown( I have no idea if that's true) but the term "brown people" wasn't used. I heard these comments from the adjoining kitchen and called in to my sister and said "sister, please interrupt our mother". She tried but was unsuccessful. In retrospect, we probably should have just answered her question. Trying to divert her just made her keep asking. DH (also in the kitchen with me) called in "hey, SIL, do you want to take this one?". His intention was to playfully mock my mother while acknowledging to his SIL that we were aware and present. This next part I didn't hear but apparently my SD, who was sitting beside her DH, said "oh look, I've found one" with the same intentions as my own DH. SIL is very dark skinned and my mother replied "no, I know who the black people are". At that point, my DS stepped in and said "let's change this conversation to literally anything else" and we all moved to sit at the table. But the damage was done. SIL was very quiet through brunch and he and SD left before dessert. I was mortified. I'm still mortified. Although I had been getting some weird vibes from SIL, I loved him and considered him an important part of our family. I spoke to my mom harshly after they left. She didn't understand why what she said was offensive and she why I was so upset with her. But she also felt badly that she upset SIL and wanted to apologize. I told her not to. Maybe that was a mistake. I truly believed that my mom attempting to apologize would only lead to her saying more offensive things.
This has gotten very long, and so much of it is painful to recall. So I'll stop here for now. And fill you all in on the aftermath next time.
- Sadielady's blog
- Log in or register to post comments
Comments
((HUGS))
Diversity in families. Im white and husband is filipino. My dad is portuguese danish mix, and has always sent me memes and funny things about filipino cultures. He is not sensitive in the least, but we live in a culturealy diverse town. So he doesnt mean it to be racist but people might be offended.
Your experiences do sound very painful. Its hard to know what to do, especially in blended families.
To understand your mother,
To understand your mother, you must be aware of her cultural differences. Portugal is a euro country with lots of diversity including Romani ethnic groups (most commonly referred as gyspy and brown ppl). In addition, Portugal has a history with North Africa and the Moors, Angola, Namibia as well as Brazilians/Latin Americans. This could explain why she may have some recollections of some portuguese ppl being referred to as brown or dark IF what she said is based on truth and not a confused memory or some sort of anachronism
Your mother was very out of line towards your SIL but its not about what was said but the intent. At the end of the day, your mother is a 78yo portuguese woman immigrant in Canada and her views on things will be different based on her age and cultural background. I would not have taken it seriously if i were your SIL. Just an old lady talking. Old ppl have lived long lives and sometimes can be a bit anachronistic while recalling their existence...I doubt your mother is racist at all but she may have certain biases based on her age or her culture just like anyone else.
I think that should not have an impact on your relationship with your in laws but you should probably apologize on behalf of your mother and explain her age and mental state. Its not really realistic to have expectations from the elderly to be 100% PC....just let ppl be who they are
You have to take into account
You have to take into account the culture of Canada, too, though. They are very intolerant of caucasians discussing race at all. There was just a story in the news about a school principal who was white who spoke in a diversity training for his job, and he was pretty harshly criticized. He ended up killing himself.
Editing to add, i agree with the sentiment that caucasians should respectfully listen to others' experiences and ideas, instead of trying to "whitesplain" the idea of culture or race. But this was a 78-year-old Portuguese woman asking what it means to be considered a "brown person", and OP admits that their response was to intentionally "playfully mock" her. Maybe Grandma has always identified as such and truly wanted to know what it means? Answering her question in an age and culturally appropriate way may have prevented her from continuing, and would have been more respectful to her as an elder.
No doubt had they answered
No doubt had they answered the question de facto, it would have probably ended there. What is done is done and there is no turning back but I find it immature that this one single event was taken at face value. Portuguese, italian, spanish and greeks are not viewed the same by anglos so it is possible that her experience in the 60s was different. Not only that, but even irish were viewed negatively by anglos. She probably was trying to connect based on the discrimination that she experienced but she could not do it in a respectful way and the conversation became tone deaf and ignorant.
Wtv happens I hope for OP that she can mend things by apologizing on behalf of her mother but i think its too far gone so best to leave things as is until they are open to repairing
Wish the best for everyone dealing with complicated relations and dynamics between their in laws....Its not easy to handle
Well said, 1st3rd5thWEInHell!
Well said, 1st3rd5thWEInHell! Both of your comments are well thought out.
Steplife
This one is tons to unpack.
Offensive, yes. But I doubt your moms intent was to be racist, unless you know otherwise.
As for SIL, I get how he was offended. Perhaps an apology to him from you on behalf of your momsey may do some damage contol.
Im also noting its steplife. Ya know for a SM and her family often the slightest thing said and it can become all out war. To make myself clear, I am not saying this was a slightest thing by any means, but give em something to find wrong with you or your family and the eternal war begins. I akin steplife to the out of control wildfires. The flames are impossible to contol once started, cause some are looking for a reason to burn.
Blessings
I like the wildfire
I like the wildfire description. It's very apt. There's a lot more to my story. I've made sooo many apologies, to no avail. At this point I'm convinced that although my SIL was absolutely justified in being hurt by my mother's and by the misguided way the rest of us tried to intervene, this situation provided him with the opportunity to create isolate my SD from her family. Stay tuned, there's so much more to come.
Thank you to all if you for
Thank you to all of you for understanding my mom's perspective. She was offensive. But there was no intention ot ill will involved. She was truly trying to understand. And as a woman who arrived in Canada in the 60s, at the age of 20 and knowing very little English, she's experienced discrimination herself and wouldn't knowlingly or purposefully subject someone else to it.
I imagine you were in a tough
I imagine you were in a tough position at the dinner, and it sounds like you and your family were trying to act in a way that put son-in-law's feelings first. Over your own mother's, even. It's easy for me to criticize but i don't know what i would have said in your position. I am caucasian and i don't use the term "brown people" in conversation, because i don't know enough about the connotations and experiences of other races to know if it would offend them. The only person i know who does use it is AA and she uses it to describe people who aren't white but aren't of African descent, either. Would i have said that to Grandma at the table? Idk. All i can say is that if son-in-law is using *that* incident as a reason to hate *you*, he was looking for a reason.
Rather than trying to excuse
Rather than trying to excuse grandma, it might be more useful to try to build bridges with SIL. Although you want to explain to him what she said, without knowing and assimilating what he has dealt with so far, it's not fair to expect him to "get over it because.. ".
Moving to a country where the culture is different, the language is different ( and that is HUGE), the whole world is different... This guy is the victim, he didn't ask to be offended.A little understanding would help . Explain to him WHY grandma said what she did. Let him know that you don't agree with it. Don't, please don't, drive this underground. Remember that he hasn't lived the family history like others have.
Been there, done that, still feel like an outsider for certain family members ... 40 years on.
Why on earth would you think
Why on earth would you think that I expected SIL to "get over it". That's not remotely true. I was mortified by what he experienced in my home and I validated (countless times) that every thought and feeling it caused him was valid. What came after, which I haven't blogged yet, is what made it seem like it provided an opportunity for him.