I feel like husband's being immature
Okay in order to explain this I have to give a little bit of a backstory. Married 5 months . My second marriage husband's third .I have one child a girl age 10 he has two boys 12 and 13. The 12 year old is ADHD . My mother and my brother lived nearby. Shortly after we got married all three children started doing chores for my mother and brother for an allowance..
We were having some issues with my daughter being smart mouth and Moody. .. one day I discipline her more harshly then my mother and brother thought I should. They got involved and they got angry with me. My husband supported how I discipline her. They got an angry or both of us and cause a major fight . But they said that we were wrong in front of my daughter there for taking away our power to discipline her . So for the next month-and-a-half my husband refuses to let the boys go earn their allowance ... so you finally let the boys go to work in her an allowance again but the ADHD 12 year old being lazy . His dad gets on to him for being lazy butt it really doesn't do any good. Come time to pay the kids my brother decides he's going to pay the twelve-year-old anyway so that he doesn't get his feelings hurt. But he says this in front of the other two kids . My husband found out he said that in front of my daughter now he's mad at my brother again. Says he shouldn't be telling my daughter anyting. But the only reason I think he said anything to the other two kids as so they won't feel like hey why are we working and our brother doesn't and he gets paid the same thing. Made sense to me. Now husband is mad and says boys can't go work and make their allowance again I think .he's being petty and childish ... please excuse any typos I'm using voice text to write this .
Why are either of you sending
Why are either of you sending your kids there?
They undermine your discipline. They are teaching the kids that they don't have to work but will still get rewarded. They argue with the lessons you are all trying to teach.
So, stop sending them. Set some boundaries with your family that isn't just overstepping with your kid, but with your SKs, too.
My daughter is extremely
My daughter is extremely close to her uncle and her grandmother. . And my boys love my mother and brother as well. they have gotten the point and are not getting in the discipline thing anymore. I love my mother and my brother they just went too far this last time. I'm still close to them . And I love them very much they're good people. . I don't believe in holding grudges are depriving the children of their uncles and grandparents.. I'm even still friends with my ex's father because my daughter loves her Grandpa very much and I'm not going to take her Grandpa from her. My problems was with her daddy not her Grandpa. . My stance is they did not get involved in our kids discipline this time only to explain to the other two children why . they paid each child the way they did.
I never allowed DS to take
I never allowed DS to take money from family for helping out. I would be very angry if they gave him money anyway. I was raising him the family was important and you helped out and did your part.
So yes paying all three children was completely undermining what your husband was trying to teach the children.
Hubby is not mad because my
Hubby is not mad because my brother paid all 3 kids he's mad because. My brother said something in front of the other two kids about why he was paying the one kid the same thing. . Specifically in front of my daughter . Hubby didn't care.the ADHD kid got paid too .
Why not just let the kids go
Why not just let the kids go an spend 'fun' time with the grandparents? Leave the cleaning and chance to earn or not earn money at your own home.
That way you and new husband pay the children when and if you believe they have full filled their task and have completed it sufficiently as to their individual abilities.
Do not discipline the children while grandparents can witness. If you are at grandparents and kids act up, put them in the car and leave. Do your consequence when you arrive home. That is if how you are disciplining is age appropriate and a new over the top form. I guess I'm concerned on how you worded the story above. Your mother and brother have been with an around you and your 10yr old daughter (including times you would have surely disciplined the child) and this is the first time they called you out and objected? That's kind of hard to believe unless you've recently changed the degree and/or manner. What was different about this time?
You need to find your spine
You need to find your spine and in a firm yet nice way HANDLE YOUR PEOPLE. They are not respecting you and your H as parents, and it's on you to draw a boundary (especially with your brother).
There's a big difference between holding a grudge and drawing a boundary. Your brother may not realize that you and your H are trying to instill a good work ethic in the kids, and it's your job as his sister to explain that to him. Having no kids of my own and being the "fun" grandma, I know I made mistakes with our gskids and likely stepped on some boundaries. Talk with him, and get him on your team. It takes a village to raise a child, and only one butthead to circumvent good parenting.
Handle this now. Do it for your kids, and for your marriage so you don't have any more instances of your family interfering.
I gotta ask, do you label
I gotta ask, do you label your DH as "immature" every time he has a disagreement with you about parenting? That won't help the situation. He's entitled to have his feelings about how his kids are dealt with.
I frankly think it was your brother who was being immature. Too afraid to not pay SS even though he didn't do any work. Perhaps he shouldn't be in charge of managing their work going forward.
I agree
If I were the brother and I was giving the kid money for doing little to nothing I would have made sure to let that be know to the slacker and the workers. But I would have gone further to say that it’s a one-time only thing. He slacks again, no money. Though the est scenario would be not to pay him at all
If I had been your husband I would have made the child give back the money including an apology from the child for slacking.
If the brother is the one paying then he totally gets to set the parameters. If your husband was giving allowance for those chores then perhaps the brothers statement was out of line. I do not think your DH is being immature. I think he’s attempting to pander to a kid who got told what’s what.
I would have chords around your house be what is done for allowance. If one of them wants a job doing things for your relatives let the kid and the relative handle it.
Personally I would stay out
Personally I would stay out of the employer/employee relationship between the kids and your family. If your kids are being *employed* by your relatives in their homes then they can pay them as they see fit. When your kids are in your home you can compensate them by giving them the allowance you think they've earned. Is this really something to fight about?
I have never told him he was
I have never told him he was childish before yesterday. And yes my mother has witnessed to me that's disciplining my daughter before but I was extremely relaxed about it. But her behavior has progressively gotten worse. I kind of wonder if some puberty hormones might have something to do with it. You also have to understand my stepsons were taken from their mother for neglect and abuse. My oldest stepson told me that his mother was never there for him. she was always busy partying and going to casinos with her friends. It got so bad my step-son attempted suicide at 11 years old while in his mother's custody. He's 13 now . After talking to Hubby and telling him that I felt like every time he got mad at them. he was threatening to take two stable adults out of his life and he was acting out by being mean to his step sister. And by the way he's not the child with ADHD. I have witnessed oldest stepson showing enormous respect for my mother and brother trying to help my mother in and out of the house in the car. Helping carry groceries in Etc .Hubby finally admitted he overreacted and agreed to let the children go back to mother and brother's house . He did ask that my brother be careful what he says in front of the kids . About the other kids ..also I agree I felt like it was an employee-employer relationship and it was brothers time and money so he could choose how to deal with it . .....by the way what does DH mean ??
Chores
All 3 kids have home chores they do not get paid for. .Money is too tight to give an allowance except for special chores. The oldest and the youngest child all responsible for dishes and laundry. They rotate this chores so that it works out more even . Middle child is responsible for cleaning the living room and feeding his dog. Just his dog not all the dogs . My daughter feeds her dogs. We had them before. But you can't simply tell him to pick up the floor and vacuum. You have to say pick up that piece of paper put that cup in the sink put away that TV tray. Every chore requires a detailed description of how to do it. It's very exhausting. We do it anyway but it's very frustrating when it would take you 5 minutes to do it yourself. But since we're trying to teach him something we end up taking 30 minutes to do a five-minute job and an adult has to supervise. Middle child is 2 years behind in school. And therefore has the same homework as my child because they're in the same grade. You will take 4 hours to do what she can get done in 30 minutes. . I will check hos answers and make him do it again. Dad would get big brother to check his answers and big brother usually didn't make sure they were right. But he's learning not to put just an answer on the paper step mom will check your answers and make him do it again. Dad would get big brother to check answers and Big brother usually didn't make sure they were right.(dad was usually at work ,and his brother had to check it) But he's learning he is getting quicker at doing homework but we're still looking at hour to an hour and a half a night.
All of that is normal for
All of that is normal for high energy kids and none of it is relevant to this issue between your husband and brother. You are expecting your husband to ignore his own parenting instincts in favor of your brother's who has already shown poor judgement. If your husband doesn't want your family members giving his kids money or anything else regarding his children, you should respect that.