Suggestions on getting toddlers to be self-sufficient?
This is just a general parenting question. Our SS2.5 is struggling with things that we feel he should have learned by now. He hasn't been potty trained yet because he can't take his pants off. He will go to the potty if we help him with his pants, but that is the only time. And I don't mean pants with buttons and zippers - even sweatpants he won't do. It is a struggle every day getting him dressed, putting his socks on (which I do understand is a hard at that age, but he won't even try), putting his coat on, even down to putting on a hat. My DF says that his bigger sister was doing all of this before she was 2!
When my fiance dropped off SS2.5 and SD5 at BM's house a few weeks ago, he watched BM do EVERYTHING for both the kids. Took their shoes off, their hats, mittens, coats, you name it, she did it. So DF says, "No wonder why he can't do anything for himself yet." BM just giggled coyly and said, "I'm such a slave for them!"
We are very patient with him and every day when we dress him, we teach him ways to try doing it ("Put your thumb inside of your boot-right there-and PUSH!" or "Put your arm through the little holes in your shirt first then I'll help you with the big hole around your head...") and we go for positive reinforcement EVERY time he tries. The issue is he gives up RIGHT away and ends up throwing a tantrum when we won't "help" him the way he wants to be helped (doing it all for him).
We realize the root of the problem is BM and that she babies him so much, but if anyone has a suggestion, let me know!
- SteppingUp's blog
- Log in or register to post comments
Comments
Boys are slower with potty
Boys are slower with potty training. MY best friend's oldest boy, who is QUITE bright, was not fully trained until almost 4. Her next boy, was done by 3, and the youngest was all set at 2.5. Boys just take longer I think. And trust me, my best friend tried EVERYTHING witht he oldest, she was at her wit's end, and she is an AMAZING mom. Her pediatrician just said...h will do it when he is ready, try not to push too much.
My daughter is 2.5 and she's
My daughter is 2.5 and she's not potty trained. She's not ready. I've done things here and there with her, but she's not ready. I'll know when she is and that's when I'll potty train her. I put her socks on her, shoes, shirt, pants, jacket, etc. I do everything for her. She's still a baby. She's only 2.5 so of course I do everything for her! She can help me, sometimes she does and sometimes she doesn't. I honestly don't think it's that big of a deal that a 2 and 1/2 year old isn't potty trained and his mother dresses him. I really don't.
Jen, are you doing pull ups
Jen, are you doing pull ups or diapers still?
diapers. She just isn't
diapers. She just isn't ready for anything else yet. I've really put effort into the research of when she will be and trying with her. It just isn't working. So I'm backing off for a while and will try again.
I think I'm getting closer though.......one of the signs is that the child won't wet the diaper at night. She's ALMOST to that point. Another is that they are uncomfortable in their "mess". She's way uncomfy in her mess! LOL! It won't be long, I'm sure. I hope.
I tried right around 2 & he
I tried right around 2 & he had no interest. I really think you have to listen to them.
Funny story, MIL tells me a few weeks ago, just let him wear his real underwear around the house, if he pees he will be uncomfortable so he won't do it. After scrubbing the couch twice in two hours, I said to heck with this. The only one uncomfortable is me cuz the couch is wet.
He actually does better about using the potty out in public OR if I let him take off his own clothes w/o me helping him.
Same here, I haven't done
Same here, I haven't done that, but i have read about it. And i know my son, he will not be uncomfortable, he would be fine with it.
Sincerely,
G
"I will die on my feet before I live on my knees"
Same here, son is 2.5 and
Same here, son is 2.5 and not trained yet, he has no desire for that... In addition, he doesn't talk all that much, says a few words. but he should have been talking long time ago!
Sincerely,
G
"I will die on my feet before I live on my knees"
Seven??? Isn't that like,
Seven???
Isn't that like, child abuse or something at a certain age? I mean, unless he has a TRUE bladder problem... SEVEN???
____________________________________________________________________
Rome wasn't built in a day, and my marriage won't be either.
I agree with Folkmom, boys
I agree with Folkmom, boys definitely take longer. As for the other things, if mom is doing everything for him he is not learning frustration tolerance. This will get worse as he gets older. We have the same issue with Creature and she's nearly 6. She HATES to do anything for herself. Her mother still wipes her butt in the bathroom, still bathes her and dresses her. Not in my house. She does it all herself here, but it took a VERY LONG TIME to break her habit of just throwing a hissy fit when she couldn't do it the first time. DH would get frustrated and help her, but when she was here alone with me. I'd let her piss and moan and struggle for as long as it took. I'd say "want to go the playground".. Creature "yah". Me "put your shoes and coat on". If it took her 2 hours to do it, then that was less play time. Sometimes she gave up and we didn't go. The key is to make them try on THEIR time to get what THEY want. Otherwise, they realize you have to eventually help them to get what YOU want. She still tries to pull crap every now and again when she knows I am in a hurry (it is a control thing). I am very calm and just say "if we're late because you're fooling around, when we return you will stand in the corner for every minute we are late".
Two and 1/2 is still very young though. Start with one task at a time and let him master that. Like start with him putting his shirt on and say "when you figure that out, I'll help with your pants and socks". Then when he gets good at it, let him do pants and shirt. Little kids don't see "getting dressed" as one task, like we do. They see it as 4 or 5, a) put shirt on b) put pants on c) put socks on, etc.
"A pessimist complains about the wind, an optimist counts on the wind changing, a realist adjusts his sails"
My nephew is still not potty
My nephew is still not potty trained, and he is 3 in June. I think each child is different, and that he will get there eventually. Perhaps you or your dh can help him practice pulling down his pants.. but, lol.. watch out.. when he learns that, he might just do it because!! lol
Right Beaccountable. If you
Right Beaccountable. If you force the child to potty train it's about as enjoyable as beating your head against a brick wall.........and that's about as far as it'll get you to! It's always best to wait until the child is ready. If you google up pottytraining, it'll give a large list of things to look for when a child is ready. They are right on.
BS 2.5 is not potty trained
BS 2.5 is not potty trained yet. He is about 60% on #1, no interest in doing #2 on the potty. He is very smart & self sufficent in other ways. He can make his own sandwhich, take off his clothes, shoes, hangs up his own coat & hat. Every kid gets it at their own time. Sometimes I think moms do too much for their kids to make things go faster. We all have so much on our plates these days.
Potty training tip: my
Potty training tip: my sister used a thing called a "Potty Watch" for my niece. Google it... cutest thing ever. She wore it around her wrist and when the alarm went off it played the potty song so she knew it was time to sit on the potty chair to try to peepee. It got her used to trying to get her pants up and down to sit on the potty and try to go. Who thinks up this stuff? lol
Potty watch huh? I like!!
Potty watch huh? I like!! Baby girl is gonna have to get a watch I'm thinking.
It's hysterical.... hers was
It's hysterical.... hers was a miniature toilet seat that played a potty song! LOL
Well, My daughter was potty
Well, My daughter was potty trained at 2-2 1/2. But, all children develop at different rates. On average, most children are potty trained by 3. Because by 3 most are entering preschool and most preschools arent licensed for children that are not yet potty trained. But if he is having trouble with his clothes then this could be 1 of 2 things. 1. He is really not yet capable of pulling his pants up and down. He will learn soon. 2. the BM has babied the child way too much and he has learned that he really doesnt need to do it himself because mom is always there to do it for him.
If number 2 is the reason, then your DF really needs to try to talk with the BM about this issue. At this point all you can do is encourage him. Be enthusiastic. But don't push. He will get there eventually.
Oh and btw, I wouldn't use pullups. Pullups have alot of absorbancy and this hinders the feeling of being wet Kids hate the feeling of wet undies.
~Never interrupt your enemy when she is making a mistake.~
"No-one can make you feel inferior without your consent."
Thank you for all the
Thank you for all the replies!! I do agree with you all that he will do it when he's ready. The thing is, he DOES go right to the potty when he needs to if he's not wearing pants. We did try the naked thing out (we leave him naked sometimes so he doesn't get lazy and just go in his pull-up) and it works great! When he has pants on or the pull-up on, he makes one tiny little effort to pull them off (pinches the outside of the pull up) then starts crying and wining for someone to help. We show him where to put his hands, sometimes put our hands over his and pull them down, etc...usually ends up being a tantrum. It's frustrating when every time we have him for the weekend he's getting better, then BM takes him again and the next time he's back to where he was.
I guess we'll just keep encouraging and encouraging and encouraging and praising and praising and praising when he does make an effort!
Potty watch, OMG I think I
Potty watch, OMG I think I am getting the little prince one of these!
Also I want to add that I
Also I want to add that I wasn't so concerned about the potty thing because I know he's still in the age where it's perfectly fine if he's not going on his own yet. I guess I am more concerned with his frustration level when he won't even try to do something like put his hat on because BM does that stuff for him...the kid can open those tiny little clasps on DVD cases, take the DVD out and put it in the player but he can't put on a hat? I know some of you might think we are rushing him but we truly believe he is developmentally "able"...just "unwilling" because "someone" else lets him get away with it. Not trying to make it about BM...but if anyone has any more insight into dealing with the frustration part because it's impossible to reason with a poor little kid that he doesn't need to cry because he can't put a hat on! It makes me feel so bad!
I know it is frustrating to
I know it is frustrating to watch and he is so young it is a tough call, but if you know he is able and just unwilling to put in the effort, don't force him, but don't do it for him either. Creature will sometimes bring a board game or some other toy and sit on the floor in front of me and dh grunting, kicking, crying, etc because she can't open it. We completely ignore it. If it isn't something he absolutely needs to have done, don't do it for him (if you know he can do it without help), but don't engage him in arguments about it either. Sometimes it is a control issue and low frustration tolerance (which leads to depression and poor coping skills down the line). Give him space to work it out without lending a hand or pushing him. This has worked with Creature.
"A pessimist complains about the wind, an optimist counts on the wind changing, a realist adjusts his sails"