You are here

Punishments for Lying?

StarStuff's picture

Hey guys,

We've had a lot of trouble with SD8 lying lately. It's usually small stuff, but it's been happening more and more frequently. We don't want her to become a compulsive liar like BM, so we're taking this very seriously. We've been practicing positive reinforcement for truth-telling.

Last week SD lied about something that was a huge deal. She lied to FDH and I, plus her teacher. Then she made up even more elaborate stories to cover up her lies to try to avoid getting into trouble. Needless to say, she failed miserably at it. We've tried yelling, spanking, grounding, taking away privileges, calm discussions, etc. You name it, we've tried it. Oh, and also sentence writing. Well today, I was discussing with FDH that I felt since SD has been so good at being grounded (no whining or complaining, doing tasks as assigned when asked) that I had decided to start giving SD back some small privileges until her grounding period is officially over Monday after school. Well SD ruined all that by lying to us yet AGAIN about something that happened at school today. The teacher has been having trouble with SD talking in class. Today SD had to be asked to be quiet 3 times in as many minutes literally. This was during a test and the teacher explained to us that SD and another kid that sits by her were both done with the test and were just chit-chatting. The teacher explained all of this to us in front of SD. As soon as we got in the car, SD came up with a big story about how she had not just been talking about random stuff, but that other kids had been asking SD to help them cheat and she was busy telling them "no". Well, this may have happened once, but not all three times and SD eventually fessed up to lying about that too. Come on, the kid that she was talking to was DONE with the test, so wouldn't have needed the answers.

So my question is, do any of you wise ladies and/or gents have any good advice about another approach to take on this? Anything that has worked for yall in the past? Currently SD is grounded, still writing 100 sentences a day(which last night was originally the last night of that until she lied today), no tv, no computer, helping with chores. SD is intelligent. We do think that she has ADHD and are currently in the process of getting her tested, and I do think that her forgetfullness and impulsiveness play in to why she's lying. We just currently feel that everything we're trying has no effect. I feel a bit defeated and lost, to be honest. We're not punishing her b/c we're mean, but because we care about her and her future. We know she is better than this, and as previously stated, we are doing all we can to ensure that she doesn't end up like her sociopathic, cumpulsively lying BM.

Any suggestions/advice would be greatly appreciate. Thanks guys!

Comments

StepX2's picture

I would explain how important it is for you and her dad to be able to trust her, especially as she gets older and starts wanting to go out and do things with her friends. Explain that if you can’t trust her then you’ll be very cautious about her going out as you have to be able to trust that she makes good choices and with her lying you don’t feel that right now with her.
Since she doesn’t sound like a terrible kid and is very bright, to have the trust of the people she cares about may mean a lot to her. On the other hand, with her being very smart, she may also know how to get better at lying. :? All the more reason to try and get it under control know.
Good luck! Smile

StarStuff's picture

I guess we'll just keep doing what we've been doing then - making sure the grounding stays consistent. As of today she has earned back a toy computer that has educational games on it (not a real computer) and is allowed to play with her friend next door. No more sentence writing either, but she is still grounded from tv and regular computer use for a couple more days.

bt-sped-gf's picture

Keep doing what you are doing, for every single lie she tells. Consistency will be the key to getting it under control. She is going to test her limits as much as she can to see if you will change.

goaway's picture

Wow reading your post sounds like my ex stepd who is gone now...We tried everything even going to the school and meeting with all the teachers and the counselor to finally discuss what is really going on and she just broke down in front of everyone and put on a sob show..it didn't stop and lies got worse to the point that as i'm sure you read my previous posts wanted her out of the house. I hope you don't have to come to that point but i wish you the best...